Mechanical Failure Analysis
Define
A backyard porch deck experienced a sudden, unexpected structural failure when a critical turnbuckle—responsible for maintaining static support—snapped after 18 years of service.
-
Turnbuckle failure posed immediate safety hazards
-
Original specifications and maintenance history were unavailable
-
Root cause of failure was uncertain, demanding forensic investigation
​
Current State: Turnbuckle Reliability
Turnbuckles maintain tension in load-bearing structures, but long-term fatigue, material degradation, and environmental exposure can compromise performance. Without historical data, predicting failure modes is extremely challenging.
​
Structural & Safety Consequences
-
Immediate risk of collapse and personal injury
-
Unknown load capacity for remaining deck components
-
Potentially costly replacement and liability exposure
​
Homeowners requested a forensic investigation to determine the cause of failure and provide guidance for safer structural designs.
Goal
Lead a full forensic engineering investigation to:
-
Identify the root cause of turnbuckle failure
-
Determine contributing factors including material, geometry, and loading
-
Extract insights to guide safer, fatigue-resistant design strategies for future structures
​
Mission: Ensure long-term structural reliability through evidence-based forensic engineering, even under incomplete data conditions.
Approach
Empathize
-
Gathered historical context from the deck owner
-
Documented installation, usage patterns, and environmental exposure
-
Mapped real-world constraints including long-term static loading, weather exposure, and maintenance gaps
​
Define Core Engineering Problem
Determine why the turnbuckle failed after nearly two decades and identify the mechanism of fracture without original specifications.
​
Investigation Goals
-
Identify fracture origin and propagation path
-
Evaluate all plausible failure modes: stress corrosion cracking, tensile overload, manufacturing defects, fatigue
-
Integrate hands-on experimental evidence with engineering analysis
-
Deliver actionable insights for material selection and structural design
​
Ideate / Hypothesis Generation
-
Considered multiple failure mechanisms:
-
Stress corrosion
-
Tensile overload
-
Material or manufacturing defects
-
Fatigue
-
-
Developed testable hypotheses linking observed fracture features to potential causes
​
Prototype / Experimental Investigation
-
Conducted visual and optical microscopy to document fracture morphology
-
Used Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to distinguish brittle vs. ductile fracture features and locate crack origins
-
Applied Energy-Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS) to confirm alloy composition
-
Performed fatigue analysis to link crack propagation to cyclic loading patterns
​
Test
-
Compared fracture patterns to reference materials and failure mode benchmarks
-
Quantified critical crack sizes and stress intensity factors
-
Evaluated evidence against each hypothesized failure mode
​
Iterate
-
Refined understanding as data ruled out hypotheses (stress corrosion, overload, defects)
-
Focused on fatigue as the dominant failure mechanism
-
Synthesized experimental observations with calculations to confirm root cause
Impact
-
Turnbuckle failure caused by fatigue crack propagation, culminating in sudden fracture
-
Material choice (zinc-aluminum alloy) and load limitations were key contributing factors
-
Provided actionable guidance for improved material selection, design margins, and maintenance strategies
Key Takeaways
-
Demonstrates advanced proficiency in forensic engineering, microscopy, and failure analysis
-
Shows ability to translate ambiguous, real-world structural problems into precise mechanical understanding
-
Emphasizes importance of material evaluation, fatigue design, and proactive maintenance
-
Highlights evidence-based decision-making to prevent catastrophic structural failures
​
This project reflects my approach to engineering: analyze meticulously, investigate systematically, and engineer solutions informed by real-world evidence.